The Hotness
Games|People|Company
Scythe: Digital Edition
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Portal 2
Borderlands 2
Dragon's Crown
Surviving Mars
Mystic Vale
Age of Fear 3: The Legend
Surviving Mars: Green Planet
Master of Orion
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
Super Mario Kart
Lunar: The Silver Star Story Complete
Fallout (1997)
GoldenEye 007
Call of Duty: Finest Hour
City of Heroes
Harvest Moon: A Wonderful Life
Their Finest Hour: The Battle of Britain
Metroid Fusion
Out Run
Toonstruck
The Operational Art of War III
Anno 1404
Achtung Spitfire
Strider (NES)
Velvet Assassin
The Shivah
Journey (2012)
Age of Fear: The Undead King
Dragon Age: Inquisition
Twilight Struggle
Hacienda
Hearthstone: Heroes of Warcraft
One Finger Death Punch
Shovel Knight
Mirror's Edge: Catalyst
The Talos Principle
Cities: Skylines
Dark Souls III
Horizon Zero Dawn
NieR: Automata
The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel II
Stellaris
The Binding of Isaac: Afterbirth
Obduction
Enter the Gungeon
Call of Cthulhu: The Official Video Game
Evolution (2019)
The Operational Art of War IV
Search: Titles Only:
Article Edit | History | Editors

A Game of Thrones Moderators Rating

A Game of Thrones Play By Forum Moderators Rating

Introduction

This article is about moderatores (game masters) of A Game of Thrones: The Board Game (Second Edition) play-by-forum.

The PBF forum can be found here: Play By Forum

If you are interested in moderating a game, check out this thread. Obviously, anyone can go and start their own moderated games and set it up however they want. but you are encouraged to add your game to this wiki, and respect the order of the player list and keep it updated to reflect your invites and acceptances. Moderators can get started at their leisure.

Abour the Rating

This rating was initially created and published in this thread: Moderators rating.

Actually, this rating is not about how good are mods, but how are they rewared for their moderator's work.

Some mods give preferences to other mods when starting the game. But one may start single game as a moderator and then get his reward from other mods times by times. Is it fair?

The rating you can see below was created to justify this process. You can see there two types of points: mod points for moderating games and player points for playing games. I regard mod points as a work and player points as a reward. List is arranged by (mod points)/(player points), so you can see how much work is paid for 1 reward point by each moderator.

Moderating game as a regular mod gives you 6 mod point cause you make 6 people happier. When 2 players start a game as internal and external mod, I give 4 points for internal mod as his work is harder, and 2 to external mod.

Points for current and finished games are equal, point for abandoned games are halved. Also, all mods who had ever quit the game, are removed from the list. Substitute mods get the same points as others.
Also, dave42 is counted as a playing mod for #40.

As a player you get 4 points for current game, 2 for finished and 1 for abandoned. If you are the playing mod, you also get playing points. Substitute players do not get player points, so they are not penalised in the rating.

I always reserve some places for mods in my games, now i will use this rating for it.

This table was created manually, only points and sums were counted automatically. So the table may include many errors, I will be pleased if you help me to correct them.

I'll try to keep this rating up-to-date for some time.

This rating does not include games which do not affect A_Game_of_Thrones_PBF_Waitlist

If you think this rating is unfair, you always can make your own one on your own criteria.

SeptembreAnge

The Rating

Name
Mod


ExtMod


PlMod


Player







Current
Ended
Ab/Tmp
Current
Ended
Abandoned
Current
Ended
Abandoned
Current
Ended
Abandoned
ModPts
PlPlts
Rating
Comments
tipbruley #32.2 #32 #29 #31 18 2 9,000 Not on the WL
Paul Evans #91 #84 5 1 5,000 Not on the WL
zeMVK #13 #7 #11 #6 12 3 4,000 Not on the WL
Cal585 #27.2 #114 #165 #27 #148 #49 #69 #61 28 9 3,111
furyn #39 #42 6 2 3,000 Excluded from WL
BobbySoFamous #22 #13 6 2 3,000 Not on the WL
omegasun5 #19 #15 #20 6 2 3,000 Not on the WL
kreikkaturkulainen #2 #1 6 2 3,000 Not on the WL
TheRedGod #91 #87 #95 6 2 3,000
Ozelot #75 #93 #105 #84 #72 #98 #83 20 8 2,500 Not on the WL
Muradrim #51 #48 #65 #88 #64 #50 #27.2 #60 #54 #47 #73 #76 29 12 2,417 Not on the WL
TblaLinus #166 #44 #45 #97 #105 #149 #53 24 10 2,400
WolfandDragon #105 #123 #133 #134 #142 #144 #145 #157 #158 #159 #160 #119 #135 #129 #121 #139 #148 #151 #153 #154 #156 #162 #124 80 34 2,353
Laffs #60 #76 #54 #70 9 4 2,250 Not on the WL
Petrov123 #49 4 2 2,000 Not on the WL
DeanAU #12 #4 6 3 2,000 Not on the WL
Angryelf97 #111 #120 #131 #136 #139 #143 #146 #149 #150 #124 #129 #133 #141 #151 #154 #159 #160 #162 #117 62 34 1,824
SeptembreAnge #107 #104 #118 #151 #154 #156 #58 #53 #43 #68 #90 #73 #83 #96 #117 #72 #109 #120 #121 #123 #130 #148 #153 #155 #157 #56 #65 #81 #88 #85 #108 #99 #102 #110 #95 96 53 1,811
zovlah #121 #130 #59 #107 #129 #63 #73 18 12 1,500
layph #56 #42 #85 #98 #47 #45 #71 #117 18 12 1,500
grimmymail #14 #13 #1 6 4 1,500 Not on the WL
dave42 #69 #66 #52 #40 #27.2 #46 #46.2 #67 #74 19 13 1,462 Not on the WL
Tuzzo90 #55 #108 #64 #74 #130 6 5 1,200
oyabun #47 #51 #31 #65 #43 #85 12 10 1,200 Not on the WL
Barabasse89 #122 #108 #110 #131 #148 #160 #102 #109 18 16 1,125
zbardou #33 #26 #58 #37 #22 #6 #33.2 #16 12 11 1,091 Excluded from WL
kevManiac #79.2 #148 #79 #89 #80 #120 #143 #144 #145 #99 24 22 1,091
Norrab #57 #86 #143 #59 #65 #88 #99 12 12 1,000
arnaudgf #18 #54 #15 #7 #72 #97 10 10 1,000 Not on the WL
fantastory #49 #56 2 2 1,000 Not on the WL
PerryTom #113 #41 #37 #81 #114 #122 #54 #44 #40 #32.2 #32 #68 #85 #99 24 24 1,000 Not on the WL
1awesomeguy #1 #13 8 8 1,000 Not on the WL
Evershifter #30a #30b #141 #157 #22 #31 12 12 1,000
Dolus #8 #9 #1 #48 #57 #69 #10 9 9 1,000 Not on the WL
tahatmat #78 #98 #75 6 6 1,000
gamer42_au #24 #63 #104 #34 #19 #23 10 11 0,909
dejam #98 #71 #99 #78 #149 #157 #56 #42 #49 #119 18 20 0,900
DarthHansen #36 #3A #4A #38 #31 6 8 0,750 Not on the WL
damiconj #87 #91 #96 3 4 0,750
Sikslik7 #80 #104 #133 6 8 0,750
Pigeon34 #92 #64 #50 #98 #114 #142 #56 #65 #81 #91 16 22 0,727 Not on the WL
charemski #163 #35 #52 #122 #145 #146 #40 #42 #60 #67 #49 #85 #90 #99 18 28 0,643
lalalazoomzoomzoom #34 #28 #98 #48 #35 #29 #63 #83 10 16 0,625
HodorHodor #74 #60 #70 #76 3 5 0,600 Excluded from WL
th30r1st #137 #127 #122 #113 #139 #146 #148 12 20 0,600
HouseNestor #77 #119 #94 4 7 0,571
smithdj08 #46 #54 #88 #46.2 #33.2 #27.2 #142 #162 #48 #41 #33 #27 #60 #69 #99 #127 #74 #76 17 34 0,500
PimpMario #31 #80 #105 #30a #30b 6 12 0,500
Svante #116 #120 #123 #145 6 12 0,500
IronyThrown #153 #159 #142 #144 6 12 0,500
poimu #67 #78 #47 #52 #91 #81 #90 6 14 0,429 Not on the WL
Phagos #102 #113 #130 #60 #108 #64 #83 #74 6 17 0,353
phx1jjm #11 #111 #143 #28 #26 #13 #7 #20 #16 6 18 0,333
nightlyraver #141 #120 #139 #157 #25 #33 #33.2 #44 6 20 0,300
rpthomps #63 #26 #44 #66 #76 2 7 0,286 Not on the WL
Soul Potato #162 #158 #150 #144 #142 #136 #127 6 22 0,273
uncle benjen #109 #130 #108 #93 #110 2 10 0,200 Not on the WL
barmaglot #140 #118 #129 #139 #148 #150 #155 #160 #127 6 30 0,200
Arne Stark #155 #151 #140 #129 #118 #156 #117 #97 #90 #66 #62 6 30 0,200 Not on the WL
Syntax3rror #33.2 #163 #53 #68 #96 #23 2 11 0,182
Alfonsolo #46.2 #54 #36 #30a #30b #7 #85 2 12 0,167 Not on the WL
[What Links Here]
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.